Pular para o conteúdo
English for ALL
← Todas as questões

A ISI como organização contraditória em “The Double Mirror” (ITA 2012)

The Double Mirror

How Pakistan’s intelligence service plays both sides

____________________ By DAVID IGNATIUS

1 (...) I found that I couldn’t capture ISI’s nuances in newspaper columns. So my eighth novel, Bloodmoney, is set largely in

Pakistan; it centers on a fictional ISI and a CIA whose operations inside Pakistan have spun out of control. I describe the director

general of my imaginary ISI this way: “To say that the Pakistani was playing a double game did not do him justice; his strategy was far

more complicated than that.”

5 This Janus-like quality is true of all intelligence services, I suppose, but I have never seen an organization quite like the ISI.

It is at once very secretive and very open, yet ISI officials get especially peeved at the charge of duplicity: “I can not go on defending

myself forever, even when I am not doing what I am blamed for,” wrote one of my ISI contacts, after I had written a column noting the

organization’s “double game” with the U.S. “I shall do what I think is good for PAKISTAN, my country. I am sure you will do the same

for US.”

10 What this official wanted me to understand was that Pakistan was suffering under its own onslaught of terrorism. An ISI

briefer almost shouted at me in 2010: “Mr. David Ignatius! Look at the casualties we have suffered fighting terrorism!” We’re in

alongside the U.S., ISI officials insist. Yet they are caught in the backwash of an anti-American rhetoric they help create. The ISI’s

press cell feeds Pakistani newspapers constantly; presumably, it thinks its U.S.-bashing leaks will hide the reality of the ISI’s

cooperation. But the puppeteer has gotten caught in the strings. Anti-Americanism has taken a virulent form that threatens the ISI too.

ISI = Inter-Services Intelligence

Time, May 23, 2011 Essay Adaptado.

Fonte: Time, 23/5/2011.

Segundo o texto, a ISI é uma organização

  1. A) contraditória.
  2. B) corporativa.
  3. C) terrorista.
  4. D) cooperativa.
  5. E) autoritária.
Ver gabarito comentado

Resposta correta: A

A contradição está montada em frases que se anulam duas a duas: “It is at once very secretive and very open”, a comparação com Janus, o deus de duas faces, e o subtítulo “How Pakistan’s intelligence service plays both sides”. O ponto alto é a linha 12: a ISI coopera com os Estados Unidos e, ao mesmo tempo, alimenta a imprensa com vazamentos antiamericanos — “they are caught in the backwash of an anti-American rhetoric they help create”. O distrator D (cooperativa) é o mais forte porque a cooperação é de fato afirmada (“We’re in alongside the U.S., ISI officials insist”), mas ela é apenas um dos lados do jogo duplo, justamente o lado que o texto mostra ser contradito pela prática. C inverte o texto: a ISI sofre com o terrorismo e o combate (“Look at the casualties we have suffered fighting terrorism!”), não é apresentada como organização terrorista.

Questões relacionadas

Ver todas →

C1 Interpretação de texto Ensaio

“I cannot go on defending myself forever”: o tom da fala (ITA 2012)
The Double Mirror How Pakistan’s intelligence service plays both sides ____________________ By DAVID IGNATIUS 1 (...) I found that I couldn’t capture ISI’s nuances in newspaper columns. So my eighth novel, Bloodmoney, is set largely in Pakistan; it centers on …

A sentença I cannot go on defending myself forever, even when I am not doing what I am blamed for (linhas 6 e 7), sugere que aquele que a pronunciou

Resolver questão

C1 Interpretação de texto Ensaio

“The Double Mirror”: uma organização como nenhuma outra (ITA 2012)
The Double Mirror How Pakistan’s intelligence service plays both sides ____________________ By DAVID IGNATIUS 1 (...) I found that I couldn’t capture ISI’s nuances in newspaper columns. So my eighth novel, Bloodmoney, is set largely in Pakistan; it centers on …

Segundo o texto, é possível afirmar que

Resolver questão

C1 Vocabulário Ensaio

“Casualties”: falso cognato no ensaio da Time (ITA 2012)
The Double Mirror How Pakistan’s intelligence service plays both sides ____________________ By DAVID IGNATIUS 1 (...) I found that I couldn’t capture ISI’s nuances in newspaper columns. So my eighth novel, Bloodmoney, is set largely in Pakistan; it centers on …

A palavra casualties (linha 11)

Resolver questão