Pular para o conteúdo
English for ALL
← Todas as questões

O sentido de 'rather' em 'but rather to language itself' (ITA 2020)

If there is any doubt about the persistent power of literature in the face of digital culture, it should be banished by the recent climb of George Orwell’s 1984 up the Amazon “Movers and Shakers” list. There is much that’s resonant for us in Orwell’s dystopia in the face of Edward Snowden’s revelations about the NSA […]. We look to 1984 as a clear cautionary tale, even a prophecy, of systematic abuse of power taken to the end of the line. […] However, after “THE END” of his dystopian novel 1984, George Orwell includes another chapter, an appendix, called “The Principles of Newspeak.” Since it has the trappings of a tedious scholarly treatise, readers often skip the appendix. But it changes our whole understanding of the novel. Written from some unspecified point in the future, it suggests that Big Brother was eventually defeated. The victory is attributed not to individual rebels or to The Brotherhood, an anonymous resistance group, but rather to language itself. The appendix details Oceania’s attempt to replace Oldspeak, or English, with Newspeak, a linguistic shorthand that reduces the world of ideas to a set of simple, stark words. “The whole aim of Newspeak is to narrow the range of thought.” It will render dissent “literally impossible, because there will be no words in which to express it.” Fonte: Frost, Laura. http://qz.com/95696. Adaptado. Acesso em agosto de 2019.

Fonte: Quartz.

No trecho “but rather, to language itself”, o termo rather pode ser substituído, sem alteração de sentido, por

  1. A) to some extent.
  2. B) on behalf of.
  3. C) instead of.
  4. D) in support of.
  5. E) more exactly.
Ver gabarito comentado

Resposta correta: E

O período é “The victory is attributed not to individual rebels or to The Brotherhood […] but rather to language itself”: temos a estrutura corretiva not X but rather Y, em que rather retifica e precisa a informação anterior — daí more exactly. As opções B e D invertem o sentido, pois on behalf of (em nome de) e in support of (em apoio a) não retificam nada; A (to some extent) enfraqueceria a atribuição, quando o texto a torna categórica. O distrator realmente forte é C: instead of tem valor semântico próximo, mas não encaixa na frase, já que a preposição to que se segue (“but rather to language itself”) ficaria duplicada e a construção resultante seria agramatical.

Questões relacionadas

Ver todas →

C1 Vocabulário Editorial

ITA 2026: paráfrase de best-sellers adaptados para o cinema
Leia o texto a seguir para responder às questões 40 e 41. The decline of teenagers reading is an impact on education If you are a teenager reading this story, you are in the minority. Statistics show that 80% of teenagers do not read for pleasure on a daily ba…

Check the alternative that best rephrases the following sentence, without altering its meaning: “Speaking of all-time great books, it seems like just about every bestseller has been turned into a movie that either gives the book a bad rap or receives great reviews and overshadows the book.”

Resolver questão

C1 Vocabulário Reportagem

Tradução do título sobre IA e periódicos científicos
As scientists explore AI-written text, journals hammer out policies Many ask authors to disclose use of ChatGPT and other generative artificial intelligence “It’s all we’ve been talking about since November,” says Patrick Franzen, publishing director for SPIE,…

Considerando o teor do artigo, assinale a tradução mais coerente para o título “As scientists explore AI-written text, journals hammer out policies”.

Resolver questão

C1 Vocabulário Reportagem

ITA 2024: “like-minded” e a ideia de similaridade
On the surface, there is little to distinguish the Woolf Social Club from any other hipster hangout in Seoul, South Korea. Customers perch on wooden stools at formica tables, tapping on laptops while they sip their coffee. Records and cds line the walls, soft …

In the excerpt from the third paragraph “I wanted a space for like-minded women to meet and talk,” the underlined term expresses an idea of:

Resolver questão