Pular para o conteúdo
English for ALL
← Todas as questões

The Almost: a boneca e o desconforto da semelhança (C1)

The doll had belonged to my aunt, and the family agreed it was valuable, which is a word people use when they cannot say pleasant. It sat on the landing with its porcelain hands open, and every guest, without exception, looked at it twice. The first look was ordinary. The second was the problem. Something in the face had been made almost correctly — the eyes were the right distance apart, the mouth had the right small weight at the corners — and the almost was worse than any monster. A crude toy asks nothing of you. This one made a claim it could not honour: it promised a person and delivered wax. My cousin, who was six, refused to pass it in the dark and was told not to be silly. She was not being silly. She had simply noticed, faster than the adults did, that the closer a thing comes to being one of us, the more precisely it advertises everything it lacks.

Fonte: English for ALL (texto original).

A afirmação "the almost was worse than any monster" expressa, no conto, a ideia de que

  1. A) o horror provocado pela boneca decorre principalmente do valor material que a família lhe atribuía, o que impedia que fosse retirada do corredor.
  2. B) objetos antigos assustam mais que criaturas imaginárias porque carregam a presença de seus antigos donos, no caso a tia falecida.
  3. C) as crianças percebem ameaças reais que os adultos, condicionados pelo hábito, aprenderam a suprimir por conveniência social.
  4. D) a estranheza resulta de um defeito técnico de fabricação, já que os olhos e a boca não haviam sido posicionados com exatidão suficiente.
  5. E) o mal-estar nasce da quase perfeição da imitação, que torna evidentes as poucas propriedades humanas ausentes, ao passo que uma figura abertamente irreal nada promete.
Ver gabarito comentado

Resposta correta: E

O narrador explicita o mecanismo em "A crude toy asks nothing of you. This one made a claim it could not honour: it promised a person and delivered wax", e o fecho generaliza: quanto mais próxima do humano, mais a figura "advertises everything it lacks". A alternativa do defeito de fabricação contraria o texto, que descreve as proporções como corretas ("the eyes were the right distance apart"). A leitura sobre a percepção infantil superior é apenas um detalhe narrativo: a prima serve de ilustração do princípio, e o próprio texto atribui a ela a mesma constatação do narrador adulto, não uma faculdade distinta.

Questões relacionadas

Ver todas →

C1 Interpretação de texto Critica cultural

Born with a Publicist: o bebê e o arquivo que não esquece (C1)
A child born this year will arrive with a publicist. Before the first word is spoken, several hundred images may already exist in places the child cannot reach, captioned by people who love it and did not think to ask. The affection is genuine, which is what m…

A menção ao álbum de fotografias da avó cumpre no texto a função de

Resolver questão

C1 Interpretação de texto Memoria

Covered by a Thumb: o avião e a escala perdida (C1)
The first time I flew I was eleven, and I spent the whole descent trying to find our house. What I remember is not the view but the discovery that everything I considered enormous — the river, the bus route that took an hour, the distance between my school and…

A afirmação "I was insulted on behalf of the walking I had done" revela que o narrador

Resolver questão

C1 Interpretação de texto Artigo de opinião

One Justification at a Time: o zoológico e seus argumentos sucessivos (C1)
Zoos have survived by changing their reason for existing roughly once a generation. They began as displays of dominion — proof that a ruler could hold the far edges of the world behind a fence. When that became embarrassing, they became educational. When the c…

Segundo o autor, a sucessão de justificativas adotadas pelos zoológicos

Resolver questão